Wednesday, January 08, 2014

Writing a poetry analysis: WIllow and Ginkgo

In section 3, we spent 30 minutes discussing the following poem.  We will discuss this further tomorrow.  The other two classes will get to this depth tomorrow.  Students are being taught how to analyze a poem.  We will use the same prompt as we discuss poem after poem.  Here is how students could start a piece about the poem "Willow and Ginkgo."

 
In “Willow and Ginkgo,” Eve Merriam uses many different poetic elements to show us her observations about two trees.  She uses form, sound devices, and language in this poem to communicate the message that she is affected more by the strength of the ginkgo than she is by the beauty of the willow.


Willow and Ginkgo
by Eve Merriam


The willow is like an etching,
Fine-lined against the sky.
The ginkgo is like a crude sketch,
Hardly worthy to be signed.

The willow’s music is like a soprano,
Delicate and thin.
The ginkgo’s tune is like a chorus
With everyone joining in.

The willow is sleek as a velvet-nosed calf;
The ginkgo is leathery as an old bull.
The willow’s branches are like silken thread;
The ginkgo’s like stubby rough wool.

The willow is like a nymph with streaming hair;
Wherever it grows, there is green and gold and fair.
The willow dips to the water,
Protected and precious, like the king’s favorite daughter.

The ginkgo forces its way through gray concrete;
Like a city child, it grows up in the street.
Thrust against the metal sky,
Somehow it survives and even thrives.

My eyes feast upon the willow,
But my heart goes to the ginkgo.

Form: traditional, stanzas, rhyme scheme
Sound: rhyme, rhythm
Language: similes, word choice